The market scales puzzle & connections with ancient Egyptian mathematics
Initial Thoughts:
My initial instinct was to find the GCF for the numbers 1-40. I quickly realized this was a dead end because the GCF across a consecutive set of integers containing co-primes will always be 1, which provides no structural insight into building all numbers.
Next, I attempted to break the numbers into categories, separating the primes from composites, and evens from odds. The goal was to construct all numbers by pairing their GCFs, but this approach proved overly complicated, and we just needed 4 numbers to construct all the other numbers.
I realized that instead of looking at the static properties of individual numbers, the problem needed a linear combination of the place values. So using your hint, I shifted my thinking to base-system representation of numbers.
We need just 4 numbers to represent all 1-40 numbers, and that’s when I thought of base 3 with possible powers 0, 1,2,3 for 4 numbers (1,3,9,27; also 1+3+9+27= 40)

For one-pan problem
We need 5 weights, so we can’t use an upper base, as then we would need fewer weights. Therefore, I switched to base 2.
2^0=1
2^1=2
2^2=4
2^3=8
2^4=16

Puzzle Extension:
As an extension, I would ask my students to verify and justify whether base 3 will work for all numbers greater than 40.
Similarly, would base 2 work for any number greater than 31? Why or why not? Followed up with an explanation to check whether any other base would work for numbers up to 40. Why or why not?
Lastly, can they come up with a general rule for such questions?
Connections
The puzzle gave me an opportunity to represent numbers using different bases; previously, I thought that bases are just used in computing or cryptography. But it has solved a real-life problem, which is fascinating to me. Also, I was impressed to see how the structural boundaries generate different procedures and rules of the number systems
This puzzle shows how potential number systems are actually optimal designs for efficiency under physical constraints.
For 2 pans, we have two options to add or subtract, may be left pan is adding the weight, and the right pan can be used to subtract the weight. For the 1-pan problem, we can just add the weight or just take it off the scale that gives another angle to use base 2 (1 for add, 0 for taking off). The operational rule changes with the changing of the physical boundary.
Comments
Post a Comment